US Coins > nickel > Buffalo Nickel

1916 S Buffalo Nickel

Useful Sites..

NGC

eBay

- In One Click
- With Details
+ Collection
+ Wishlist
Buy/Sell
Item Details
Show Historic Prices

Add this item to your collection.
Keep track of your collection value over time. Ok

Compare vs Other Items

Ungraded	VF (20-35)	AU (50-58)	MS62	MS64	MS66
$19.49 +$7.12	$65.18 $0.00	$167.19 -$1.49	$255.29 +$0.04	$743.40 +$0.27	$5,280.00 $0.00	+
volume: 2 sales per day	volume: 6 sales per year	volume: 2 sales per month	volume: 1 sale per month	volume: 5 sales per year	volume: 2 sales per month	+

MS62	MS64	MS66
$255.29 +$0.04	$743.40 +$0.27	$5,280.00 $0.00
volume: 1 sale per month	volume: 5 sales per year	volume: 2 sales per month

Ungraded Sold Listings (30)

VF Sold Listings (13)

AU Sold Listings (30)

MS62 Sold Listings (22)

MS64 Sold Listings (14)

MS66 Sold Listings (2)

All Sold Listings

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-03-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel ~ Fine/Very Fine (F/VF) ~ Semi-Key Date! ~ 1 Coin San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$37.98	Report It
2025-03-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel -RESTORED DATE San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-03-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel in a HIGHER GRADE San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$104.73	Report It
2025-03-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S San Francisco Mint Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$38.25	Report It
2025-03-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Good (G) Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Mint San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$8.95	Report It
2025-03-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel -- Choice VF "Better Date" San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$5.50	Report It
2025-03-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel -RESTORED DATE San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-03-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel -RESTORED DATE San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-03-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel Good/VG Five Cent Coin Free & Fast Shipping #326 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$7.65	Report It
2025-03-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel Semi-Key Date Restored Five Cent 5c Coin C909 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$4.45	Report It
2025-03-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Full Date Near Full Horn High Grade VF/XF Buffalo Nickel Nice US Coin! San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel Nice FN Fine Condition Better Date 5c Coin (Raw15257) San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$19.95	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel * Good G * XB249 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$9.97	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel Very Fine VF Coin #10165 San Francisco [eBay]	$27.95	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel Very Fine VF Coin #10164 San Francisco [eBay]	$27.50	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel Semi-Key Date Restored Five Cent 5c Coin C639 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$4.95	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S San Francisco Mint Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$29.00	Report It
2025-03-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel F San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$14.00	Report It
2025-03-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S buffalo nickel Philadelphia Buffalo [eBay]	$34.97	Report It
2025-03-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel - Scarce Semi-key Better Date No Reserve #A8111 [eBay]	$6.76	Report It
2025-02-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S San Francisco Mint Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$15.50	Report It
2025-02-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S San Francisco Mint Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$47.89	Report It
2025-02-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL FOUR DIGIT DATE #3142e San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$14.95	Report It
2025-02-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel \| Semi-Key Date \| Circulated \| Free Shipping San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$15.99	Report It
2025-02-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel (bb17548) San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$6.00	Report It
2025-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$6.99	Report It
2025-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 P Buffalo Nickel - Scarce Better Date (S)-S Philadelphia Buffalo [eBay]	$12.95	Report It
2025-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	🇺🇸 1916 S 5c Indian Buffalo Nickel 🦬 ^WWI Era WiLdWeStCOASt beaChbuMbiSON ☀️ San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$9.10	Report It
2025-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	🔥 1916-S Buffalo Nickel VG 🔥 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$6.27	Report It
2025-02-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel - Very Fine + Condition - 122SU Buffalo [eBay]	$19.50	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-12-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel (VF35) NGC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$99.99	Report It
2024-08-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S PCGS VF30 Buffalo Nickel item#P18779 Buffalo [eBay]	$55.00	Report It
2024-06-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS VF35 Nice Eye Appeal Nice Strike San Francisco [eBay]	$45.00	Report It
2024-05-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel graded VF30 by ANACS Soapbox Holder Mid Grade Original San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$69.99	Report It
2024-05-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5C Buffalo Nickel ANACS Graded VF25 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$60.00	Report It
2024-02-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5C BUFFALO NICKEL NGC VF20 #6849316-025 FRESHLY GRADED! San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$69.99	Report It
2024-01-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5c ICG - VF20 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$40.00	Report It
2023-11-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel 5c ICG VF25 #65201 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$44.99	Report It
2023-07-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel (VF35) NGC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$50.00	Report It
2023-06-28		1916 S Buffalo Nickel ANACS VF20 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$29.00	Report It
2023-04-15		NGC VF-35! 1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$59.00	Report It
2023-03-06		1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL ANACS VF20 Buffalo [eBay]	$23.50
2023-01-16		1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5c ICG - VF20 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$49.00

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S .05 ANACS AU 50 Buffalo Nickel, Indian Nickel, 5 Cent Piece San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$237.00	Report It
2025-02-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel ANACS AU 55 - FREE SHIP! G1060 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$122.40	Report It
2025-02-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL, NGC GRADED AU 55 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$185.00	Report It
2025-01-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL - PCGS AU-53 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$145.00	Report It
2025-01-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel NGC AU58 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$169.99	Report It
2024-10-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel AU58 PCGS PQ *4470 San Francisco [eBay]	$210.00	Report It
2024-10-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel : ANACS AU53 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$139.99	Report It
2024-09-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5c - NGC AU58 - High Grade Better Date San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$249.00	Report It
2024-08-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS AU 53#I574 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$129.00	Report It
2024-08-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C AU55 PCGS VALUE $175 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$127.50	Report It
2024-06-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5c - PCGS AU58 - High Grade Better Date San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$220.00	Report It
2024-06-05		1916-S 5C AU53 PCGS. Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$95.00	Report It
2024-05-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S PCGS AU55 Buffalo Nickel, Lustrous Almost Uncirculated Coin UNC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$149.99	Report It
2024-05-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS AU58 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$135.99	Report It
2024-05-07	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	CHOICE 1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5C Choice AU-55 NGC Early Date FREE SHIPPING San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$139.95	Report It
2024-05-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL ANACS AU-50 DETAIL - ABOUT UNCIRCULATED - BETTER DATE - 5C San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$95.00	Report It
2024-04-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5C BUFFALO NICKEL NGC AU55 #2147138-043 FRESHLY GRADED! San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$149.99	Report It
2024-04-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL AU55 ANACS San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$125.99	Report It
2024-03-17	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL AU55 ANACS San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$113.70	Report It
2024-03-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S NGC AU BUFFALO NICKEL ABOUT UNCIRCULATED 5C Coin BUY IT NOW! San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$99.00	Report It
2024-02-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5c Buffalo Nickel NGC AU 55 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$189.99	Report It
2024-02-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S PCGS AU53 Choice AU Buffalo Nickel - Lustrous, and Nicely Toned, PQ! San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$149.00	Report It
2024-01-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S 5 Cent Buffalo Nickel US Mint NGC AU58 About Unc Rare [eBay]	$212.00	Report It
2024-01-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS AU 55#I575 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$129.00	Report It
2024-01-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS AU55 CAC Approved San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$210.00	Report It
2023-12-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo nickel, NGC AU58, exceptional originality DavidKahnRareCoins San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$175.00	Report It
2023-12-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	NobleSpirit No Reserve) 1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS AU 55 [eBay]	$105.70	Report It
2023-11-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel NGC AU 55 Better Date! San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$159.50	Report It
2023-11-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel NGC AU58 Beautiful Coin, Rich Patina WCLA San Francisco [eBay]	$263.99	Report It
2023-11-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5c PCGS AU55 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$180.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-12-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5C PCGS MS62 Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$299.99	Report It
2024-11-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel MS62 ICG *1427 San Francisco [eBay]	$99.95	Report It
2024-10-10		1916-S 5C MS62 PCGS. Mintage 11,860,000. ... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$228.00	Report It
2024-07-17	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5c Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS62 Old Holder, Nice and Original Coin! San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$342.00	Report It
2024-05-14		1916-S 5C MS62 PCGS. Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$240.00	Report It
2024-05-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel - PCGS MS 62 - Gold Shield San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$297.00	Report It
2024-03-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS62 San Francisco [eBay]	$282.99	Report It
2024-01-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS MS62 495 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$158.50	Report It
2023-12-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel NGC MS62 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$285.00	Report It
2023-11-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	BU 1916-S Buffalo Nickel NGC MS62 Great Luster for the Grade! XNRW San Francisco [eBay]	$369.99	Report It
2023-11-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S 5C NGC MS 62 Buffalo Nickel, Better Semi-KEY Date, Uncirculated Coin San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$239.49	Report It
2023-10-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS62 Great Eye Appeal Strong Strike San Francisco [eBay]	$260.00	Report It
2023-08-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel * PCGS MS62 * Mintage 11,860,000 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$300.00	Report It
2023-08-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	NGC MS-62! 1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$243.00	Report It
2023-07-09		1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5C PCGS MS62 CAC [eBay]	$345.00	Report It
2023-06-04		1916-S Buffalo Nickel Semi - Key Date NGC MS62 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$275.00	Report It
2023-03-24		1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL ✪ PCGS MS-62 ✪ 5C UNCIRCULATED UNC BU COIN ◢TRUSTED◣ San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$295.00	Report It
2023-02-05		1916-S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS62 Certified -5 Cents- DM460 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$250.00
2023-01-09		1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS62 CAC Old Holder with Tone San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$289.99
2023-01-03		1916-S 5C MS62 NGC. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$192.00	Report It
2022-12-08		1916-s buffalo nickel - PCGS Graded MS62 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$204.50
2022-04-12		1916-S 5C MS62 PCGS. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$204.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-10-10		1916-S 5C MS64 PCGS. Mintage 11,860,000. ... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$660.00	Report It
2024-07-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS-64 San Francisco [eBay]	$901.00	Report It
2024-04-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 NGC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$929.00	Report It
2024-01-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS64 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$471.66	Report It
2023-12-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS MS64 - VERY PQ! San Francisco [eBay]	$925.00	Report It
2023-10-12	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5c Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS64 Incredible Eye Appeal 🌈🔥🫐🦬👀🤯 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$915.00	Report It
2023-10-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS64 San Francisco [eBay]	$706.25	Report It
2023-04-04		1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS MS64 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$425.00	Report It
2023-01-24		1916-S 5C MS64 NGC. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$660.00	Report It
2022-12-22		1916-S 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS64 San Francisco [eBay]	$717.55
2022-11-29		1916-S 5C MS64 NGC. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$504.00	Report It
2022-11-22		1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C PCGS CERTIFIED MS 64 MINT STATE (595) SAN FRANCISCO [eBay]	$749.97
2022-08-30		1916-S 5C MS64 PCGS. CAC. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$1,320.00	Report It
2022-03-21		1916-S 5C MS64+ PCGS. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$720.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-02-11		1916-S 5C MS66 PCGS.... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$4,800.00	Report It
2025-02-11		1916-S 5C MS66 PCGS.... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$5,760.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-07-31	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS F12 F 12 FINE San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$44.00	Report It
2024-07-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel (F 12) NGC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$22.20	Report It
2023-12-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel (Fine 12) NGC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$16.50	Report It
2023-03-25		1916 S 5C Buffalo Nickel ANACS F 15 \| Fine San Francisco San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$49.95	Report It
2023-03-12		1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS F 12 #MF-T1174 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$12.69

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-03-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5C Buffalo Nickel ICG EF 45 Lamination San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$69.00	Report It
2024-10-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS XF 45 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$110.00	Report It
2024-10-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC XF45 Extremely Fine Semi Key Date Coin San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$99.99	Report It
2024-09-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S XF-40 - BETTER DATE BUFFALO NICKEL - PCGS GRADED COIN San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$71.55	Report It
2024-09-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel - 5c PCGS XF40 - Better Date San Francisco Buffalo Nickel [eBay]	$89.99	Report It
2024-08-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel from the San Francisco Mint Graded XF40 by NGC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$96.00	Report It
2024-06-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S XF40 Buffalo Nickel PCGS Extra Fine 40 ** Better Date San Francisco Issue San Francisco Buffalo Nickel [eBay]	$67.00	Report It
2024-04-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS EF45 XF45 Toned Soap Box Holder FREE SHIPPING WLC San Francisco [eBay]	$109.84	Report It
2024-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S Buffalo Nickel XF45 ANACS San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$103.55	Report It
2024-01-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS XF40 Perfect Example, Semi-Key Date JFM San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$72.79	Report It
2024-01-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS XF40 Perfect Example, Semi-Key Date JFM San Francisco [eBay]	$105.00	Report It
2023-12-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel (XF40) NGC San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$66.77	Report It
2023-12-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel 5C PCGS EXTRA FINE 45 XF 45 Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$100.00	Report It
2023-11-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5c Buffalo Nickel - NGC XF45 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$57.75	Report It
2023-09-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS XF 45 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$90.00	Report It
2023-09-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel. NGC XF45. Better Date. San Francisco Mint. San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$71.00	Report It
2023-06-10		1916 S NGC XF40 Buffalo Nickel San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$90.00	Report It
2023-06-08		1916-S San Francisco Indian Head Buffalo Nickel PCGS Graded XF40 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$85.00	Report It
2023-06-01		1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS EF 40 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$60.99	Report It
2023-05-22		1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS EF 40 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$60.99	Report It
2023-04-23		1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS EF45 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$60.00	Report It
2023-04-16		NGC-XF! 1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$55.00	Report It
2023-01-28		1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL ANACS XF40 (many other dates listed!) Books $81 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$49.99
2023-01-16		1916-S Buffalo Nickel ANACS EF 40#I576 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$64.00
2023-01-04		1916-S Buffalo Nickel * PCGS XF40 * Mintage 11,860,000 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$110.00
2022-11-26		1916 "S" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC XF40 #005 ECC&C, Inc. San Francisco [eBay]	$99.99
2022-11-13		1916-S Buffalo Nickel, NGC XF45 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$110.00
2022-11-09		1916-S XF40 PCGS Buffalo 5¢ San Francisco Buffalo Nickel [eBay]	$51.00

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this coin and condition

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-11-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel NGC MS61 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$225.00	Report It
2024-06-17	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	MS61 1916-S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel NGC *4111 San Francisco [eBay]	$236.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-01-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel, PCGS MS-63, Better Date & A Pretty Coin San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$549.00	Report It
2024-11-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel - Better Date - PCGS MS63 - Very Pretty BU Coin San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$490.00	Report It
2024-11-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS63 (CAC) San Francisco [eBay]	$455.99	Report It
2024-10-10		1916-S 5C MS63 PCGS. Mintage 11,860,000. ... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$336.00	Report It
2024-10-10		1916-S 5C MS63 PCGS. Housed in a first-generation "rattler" holder. Mintage 11,860,000.... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$492.00	Report It
2024-09-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS MS63 San Francisco [eBay]	$415.00	Report It
2024-07-01		1916-S 5C MS63 NGC. NGC Census: (181/323). Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$372.00	Report It
2024-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS-63 San Francisco [eBay]	$450.50	Report It
2024-01-26		1916-S 5C MS63 PCGS. CAC. Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$384.00	Report It
2024-01-26		1916-S 5C MS63 PCGS. Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$552.00	Report It
2023-03-14		1916-S 5c Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS63 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$595.00
2023-02-18		1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS63 UNCIRCULATED KEY DATE San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$295.00

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-02-11	1916-S 5C MS65 NGC. Ex: Yankee Collection. Mintage 11,860,000.... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$1,740.00	Report It
2024-09-02	1916-S 5C MS65 PCGS. Mintage 11,860,000. ... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$1,860.00	Report It
2024-06-05	1916-S 5C MS65 PCGS.... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$1,980.00	Report It
2024-03-05	1916-S 5C MS65+ PCGS.... Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$3,360.00	Report It
2024-01-26	1916-S 5C MS65 PCGS. Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$2,640.00	Report It
2023-07-05	1916 S Buffalo Nickel 5c Better Key High Grade San Francisco NGC MS65 Coin San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$2,495.00	Report It
2023-01-15	1916-S 5C MS65 PCGS. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$1,800.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2012-01-06		1916-S 5C MS67 NGC. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$14,950.00	Report It
1995-08-17		1916-S MS 67 PCGS. \| Buffalo Nickel [HeritageAuctions]	$14,300.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-02-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1916-S 5c Buffalo Nickel ANACS VG 10 San Francisco Buffalo [eBay]	$15.55	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this coin and condition

Click tabs to see historic sales data.
Click on a listing to see full details. Ok

1916 S (Buffalo Nickel) Details

Genre:	Nickel
Release Date:	January 1, 1916
Mintage:	n/a
Notes:	none

ePID (eBay):	none
PriceCharting ID:	4619780

Description:	none

More Photos: 1916 S Buffalo Nickel

Main Image

Full Price Guide: 1916 S (Buffalo Nickel)

Ungraded	$19.49
VG (8-10)	$15.55
F (12-15)	$29.87
VF (20-35)	$65.18
XF (40-45)	$85.77
AU (50-58)	$167.19
MS60	-
MS61	$228.91
MS62	$255.29
MS63	$478.35
MS64	$743.40
MS65	$1,860.00
MS66	$5,280.00
MS67	$14,709.95
MS68	$17,652.00
MS69	$21,182.00
MS70	$26,478.00

All prices are the current market price.

1916 S (Buffalo Nickel | US Coins) prices are based on the historic sales. The prices shown are calculated using our proprietary algorithm.
Historic sales data are completed sales with a buyer and a seller agreeing on a price. We do not factor unsold items into our prices.
Chart shows the price of 1916 S at the end of each month going back as long as we have tracked the item.